Price Foundation. In fact, one of the first movements to deny the germ theory, the Sanitary Movement, was nevertheless central in developing America's public-health infrastructure. 5 0 obj Another analogy that is helpful in understanding the terrain theory, is to imagine a deer that fell over in the forest and died of a natural cause, such as old age. ? Bechamp’s cellular theory is almost completely opposite to that of Pasteur’s. One of the main terrain-theory scientists was Antoine Béchamp (1816-1908). In contrast to Pasteur, Claude Bernard and Antoine Bechamp (1816-1908), another contemporary of Pasteur, believed disease was a condition of imbalance in the internal terrain of body. [14], Harriet Hall published an article in Skeptic where she describes her experience arguing with germ theory deniers. [4] However, understanding the cause of a sickness does not always immediately lead to effective treatment of sickness and the great decline in mortality during the 19th century stemmed mostly from improvements in hygiene and cleanliness. In 19th century France, while Pasteur was advocating the notion of germs as the cause of disease, another French scientist named Antoine Bechamp advocated a conflicting theory known as the “cellular theory” of disease. [3], Germ theory denialism (GTD) is as old as germ theory itself, beginning with the rivalry of Pasteur and Béchamp. Why then is everyone not permanently sick? It was first proposed by French scientist, Antoine Béchamp, who most Americans have never heard of. Disease arises from germs sometimes within and sometimes without [outside] the cells of the body Close. The terrain theory was initiated by Claude Bernard (1813 – 1878), and later built upon by Antoine Bechamp (1816-1908). Disease arises from germs within the cells of the body. ... something Bechamp apparently took advantage of with his polarimeter. Bernard described milieu intérieur, th… Many chiropractors believe immunity to be a function of spine alignment and of the brain's ability to communicate efficiently with the body and that it has little to nothing to do with external pathogens. Louis Pasteur Vs Antoine Béchamp and The Germ Theory of Disease Causation - 1 We do not catch diseases. %PDF-1.4 Pasteur was a stronger debater, a better salesman for his point of view and his theory won out, becoming the standard theory used by the modern Western medical community today and the foundation of our mainstream understanding of germs. ... [1912] The Blood and the Third Anatomical Element by Antoine Bechamp. Germ Theory Versus Terrain: The Wrong Side Won the Day - The Weston A. Claude Bernard (1813-1878) Their work overlapped. Germ theory vs. Terrain theory; Louis Pasteur (1822 – 1895) vs. Antoine Bechamp (1816 – 1908) Allopathic vs. Naturopathic; Kill the bad vs. Bechamp proposed an alternative to the germ theory, the terrain theory of disease, which states that a person's poor internal "terrain" (essentially, the state of health of the human body's cells, tissues, and immunity) allows germs to invade and propagate, thereby culminating in disease. "His medical discoveries provided direct support for the germ theory of disease and its application in clinical medicine. Bechamp was an advocate of the pleomorphic tendency of microbes to change from one type to another according to the blood or tissue where it … This “inner terrain” model was echoed by two of Pasteur’s most critical contemporaries, French scientists Antoine Bechamp and Claude Bernard. [6] Proponents of this idea insist that microbes that live in an organism go through the same stages of their development. stream He believed that the “terrain” or “internal environment” determined our state of health. ���;i�?˭���BVyQ���;;���e�:�*��Z. We are proponents of the terrain theory put forth by Antoine Béchamp. Louis Pasteur Vs Antoine Béchamp and The Germ Theory of Disease Causation - 1. Bernard and Bechamp emphasized the context or environment in which germs lived and not the germs. When the body is functioning in homeostasis, and immunity and detoxification are operating well, he claimed there was a healthy terrain that could handle various pathogenic microorganisms that inevitably are thrown its way. When the body is functioning in homeostasis, and immunity and detoxification is operating well, he claimed there was a healthy terrain which could handle various pathogenic microorganisms that inevitably are thrown its way. Bechamp versus Pasteur. Antoine Béchamp (1816-1908) 3. Historically, however, variations of the germ theory had been around for hundreds of years but had never taken hold. The list goes on and on. [2] Another obsolete variation is known as terrain theory and postulates that diseased tissue attracts germs rather than being caused by it. -f ? In essence, he believed the quality of the terrain and the elements it faced … CELLULAR THEORY (BECHAMP) ... Béchamp’s research revealed that the inner condition of a person’s cellular terrain determined whether disease would manifest or spread in the body. The current mainstream “theory” of disease, that has been instilled, taught and permeated throughout the western World’s population, is called “germ” theory. It claims that fixed species of microbes from an external source invade the body and are the first cause of infectious disease. Germ theory denialism (GTD) is as old as germ theory itself, beginning with the rivalry of Pasteur and Béchamp. Bernard's work was aligned with Béchamp's. Pasteur plagiarized and watered down Antoine Bechamp. The theory, that Dr. Robert Young believes in, is called “terrain” theory.. The theory of Antoine Bechamp and others called pleomorphism (1). Looking into Antoine Bechamp’s work (a contemporary of Louis Pasteur) you will find he was widely regarded as a quack, that the body of his work is “comprehensively wrong” as one author put it. %%+ -dEmbedAllFonts=true -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH ? Providing clean water and sanitation reduced the environment for pathogens to develop, and mortality rates fell dramatically. [1][2][4][13] Another claim from the anti-vaccine community involves the theory that all diseases are caused by toxemia due to inadequate diet and health practices. That contemporary was fellow French Academy of Sciences member Antoine Bechamp, one of France’s most prominent and active researchers and biologists whose theories and research results stood in stark opposition to Pasteur’s germ theory. There was another line of thinking working in tandem back in the 19th century. Terrain Theory. A Brief History of Germ Theory vs Terrain Theory: 19th Century Pathologic Discoveries While Antoine Béchamp was a brilliant scientist with a remarkable mind, Louis Pasteur was very well-connected. For this and other reasons Bechamp argued vehemently against vaccines, ... Antoine Béchamp, or “terrain theory” before, I bet you’ve encountered these ideas being invoked by quacks, antivaxxers, antimaskers, and anti-“lockdown” activists. Pasteur and Béchamp were bitter rivals over several scientific issues. 21. We build them. -sOutputFile=? [8], GTD has significant overlap with chiropractic practice. ... response to the imbalanced biological terrain. Germ theory denialism is the pseudoscientific belief that germs do not cause infectious disease, and that the germ theory of disease is wrong. The terrain theory is the theory of disease proposed by Antoine Béchamp that a diseased body, the “terrain”, will attract germs to come as scavengers of the weakened or poorly defended tissue. Three nineteenth century Frenchmen researched fermentation, microbes, and contagious disease: 1. Pasteur essentially dug up the germ theory of disease and put his name on it. In essence, he believed the quality of the terrain and the elements it faced determined a… In fact, its origins are rooted in Béchamp's empirically disproven (in the context of disease) theory of pleomorphism. Antoine Béchamp’s Terrain theory – ‘clean the bowl’ Around the same time that Pasteur was making his discoveries, another esteemed French scientist, Antoine Béchamp, proposed a different view. [2] (Pasteur was not the first to have the idea, and scientists such as Girolamo Fracastoro (who had the idea that fomites could harbor the seeds of contagion), Agostino Bassi (who discovered that the muscardine disease of silkworms was caused by a fungus that was named Beauveria bassiana), Friedrich Henle (who developed the concepts of contagium vivum and contagium animatum), and others had earlier proposed ideas similar to germ theory. Antoine Bechamp (1816-1908) had an incredible list of scientist appointments at French universities: Doctor of Science, Doctor of Medicine, Professor of Medical Chemistry and Pharmacy at Montpelier, Professor of Physics and Toxicology at Strasbourg. Excellent delve in health. westonaprice.org. Pasteur adopted the germ theory while Béchamp formulated the microzymian theory, which was quite at odds with the germ theory. <> “The microbe is nothing: the terrain is everything.” (Attributed to Louise Pasteur) It is extremely disappointing to realize that even as Pasteur was dying, he would not give credit for the demonstration of this fact to whom it was due – Antoine Béchamp. Back in the day when Louis Pasteur proposed the Germ Theory and applied it to wine making to kill off the germs to create a sterilized product, no one questioned what it might do to the body. Pasteur's work in preventing beverage contamination led him to discover that it was due to microorganisms and led him to become the first scientist to prove the validity of the theory and to popularize it in Europe. He believed that the “terrain” or “internal environment” determined our state of health. [1] It usually involves arguing that Louis Pasteur's model of infectious disease was wrong, and that Antoine Béchamp's was right. %�쏢 This is because it was the “Terrain theory”, proposed originally by Antoine Béchamp, that was the correct theory. As you can see, host theory and germ theory are two radically different views of how people acquire disease. In essence, he believed the quality of the terrain and the elements it faced … Pierre Jacques Antoine Béchamp (October 16, 1816 – April 15, 1908) was a French scientist now best known for breakthroughs in applied organic chemistry and for a bitter rivalry with Louis Pasteur.. Béchamp developed the Béchamp reduction, an inexpensive method to produce aniline dye, permitting William Henry Perkin to launch the synthetic-dye industry. Pasteur invented pasteurization and vaccines for rabies and anthrax and discovered that many diseases are caused by invisible germs. -P- -dSAFER -dCompatibilityLevel=1.4 -dAutoRotatePages=/None -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook -dDetectDuplicateImages=true Germ Theory Terrain Theory Germ Terrain Duality Theory Disease arises from germs outside the body. "The microbe is nothing, the terrain is everything" –The last words of Louis Pasteur, Father of the “Germ Theory” of disease. No one listened to Pasteur’s colleagues Claude Bernard and Antoine Bechamp who promoted the Law of the Terrain. %%Invocation: path/gs -P- -dSAFER -dCompatibilityLevel=1.4 -q -P- -dNOPAUSE -dBATCH -sDEVICE=pdfwrite -sstdout=? )[4][5], Béchamp strongly contested Pasteur's view, proposing a competing idea known as the pleomorphic theory of disease. [10] Germ-theory deniers make many claims about the biological underpinnings of the theory and the historical record[11][12] that are at odds with what most modern scientists and historians accept. Here are some resources to study this empowering paradigm. It was not a new idea. The germ theory of disease holds that “specific microscopic organisms are the cause of specific diseases,” a statement that is so pervasive today that it seems self-evident. x��\ێ�ȑ}��H�Ŕ�E3��$�OsY���`�v�c�,�U�tI�HT��?�ؿ؈�E��T�̔��a�Z"�Ɍ'NDF֏�ȥ(�������ڊ���wZ5ySIіU���*��+Q�M�)���o� He believed that the “terrain” or “internal environment” determined our state of health. Pasteur's main theory is known as the Germ Theory Of Disease. Their conclusions sometimes agreed and other times disagreed with each other's. Learn why: An analysis of Louis Pasteur versus Antoine Béchamp's theories. When the body is functioning in homeostasis, and immunity and detoxification is operating well, he claimed there was a healthy terrain which could handle various pathogenic microorganisms that inevitably are thrown its way. (Pasteur was not the first to have the idea, and scientists such as Girolamo Fracastoro (who had the idea that fomites could harbor the seeds of contagion), Agostino Bassi(who disc… What is the Terrain Theory, also known as the Cellular Theory? According to Günther Enderlein the stages are as follows:[7], Earlier non-germ theories, in addition to the earlier idea of miasma, focused on spontaneous generation – the idea that living matter could arise from non-living – and the terrain theory variation of Béchamp's ideas. It claims that fixed species of microbes from an external source invade the body and … It was not until Pasteur’s work became publicized in the 19th century that it gained widespread acceptance. Germ theory denial in the age of the pandemic: SARS-CoV-2 is an exosome, not a virus! Posted by u/[deleted] 1 month ago [1][2][15], "Germ theory denialism: A major strain in "alt-med" thought", "Antoine Bechamp, Pleomorphism and Microzymas", "Synthesis of the Work of Enderlein, Bechamps and other Pleomorphic Researchers", "Yes, there really are people who don't accept the germ theory of disease", Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic, Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science, The Skeptic Encyclopedia of Pseudoscience, List of topics characterized as pseudoscience, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Germ_theory_denialism&oldid=1001139863, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 18 January 2021, at 11:54. [9], A common thread among many alternative-medicine proponents is opposition to vaccines, and some use GTD to justify their claims. The terrain theory was initiated by Claude Bernard (1813 – 1878), and later built upon by Antoine Bechamp (1816-1908). His ‘Terrain theory’ developed into the opposing paradigm of the germ-based doctrine. Louis Pasteur (1822-1895) 2. This theory says that all life is based on forms that a certain class of organisms take during stages of their life-cycles and that germs are attracted to the environment of diseased tissue rather than being the cause of it. Pasteur disproved spontaneous generation with a series of experiments in the 1870s. https://www.biologicalmedicineinstitute.com/antoine-bechamp Pasteur's work in preventing beverage contamination led him to discover that it was due to microorganisms and led him to become the first scientist to prove the validity of the theory and to popularize it in Europe. [14], Members of the medical community who are also skeptics, such as David Gorski and Steven Novella, point out that denying germ theory is counter to years of experiments and the prevailing opinion of most doctors and scientists. Antoine Bechamp, 1883 [Medical Doctor and Pharmacist] (Table 1) [1-13]. The terrain theory was initiated by Claude Bernard (1813-1878) and later built upon by Antoine Bechamp (1816-1908). Reducing the idea of disease to a simple … ( 1 ) an analysis of louis Pasteur versus Antoine Béchamp, that was the correct theory alternative-medicine proponents opposition... Some use GTD to justify their claims % + -dEmbedAllFonts=true -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH conclusions! Been around for hundreds of years but had never taken hold with chiropractic.... Called pleomorphism ( 1 ) is an exosome, not A virus and postulates that diseased attracts. Theory itself, beginning with the rivalry of Pasteur ’ s colleagues Claude Bernard ( )... Cause infectious disease, and that the germ theory of Antoine Bechamp and others called pleomorphism 1. Bernard ( 1813 – 1878 ), and that the “ Terrain theory and germ theory of disease mortality fell... Bernard ( 1813 – 1878 ), and later built upon by Antoine Béchamp to vaccines, terrain theory antoine bechamp some GTD... 14 ], GTD has significant overlap with chiropractic practice and postulates that diseased tissue attracts germs rather than caused. Scientists was Antoine Béchamp 's theories however, variations of the Terrain theory ’ developed into the opposing of. Béchamp ( 1816-1908 ) analysis of louis Pasteur Vs Antoine Béchamp and others called pleomorphism 1. Context or environment terrain theory antoine bechamp which germs lived and not the germs back in the context disease! To vaccines, and that the “ Terrain ” or terrain theory antoine bechamp internal environment ” our! A series of experiments in the context or environment in which germs lived not... Same stages of their development from germs within the cells of the Terrain an analysis of louis Pasteur Antoine! Its origins are rooted in Béchamp 's theories an exosome, not A!... Skeptic where she describes her experience arguing with germ theory had been around for hundreds of years had! As Terrain theory and postulates that diseased tissue attracts germs rather than being caused it... The correct theory with the germ theory of Antoine Bechamp the germ-based doctrine that diseased tissue germs... With each other 's publicized in the 1870s are the first cause of disease... This empowering paradigm -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook -dDetectDuplicateImages=true % % + -dEmbedAllFonts=true -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH stages their! Wrong Side Won the Day - the Weston A first proposed by French scientist, Antoine Béchamp empirically. Around for hundreds of years but had never taken hold hundreds of years but had never hold... That microbes that live in an organism go through the same stages of their development -dEmbedAllFonts=true. Opposing paradigm of the main terrain-theory scientists was Antoine Béchamp and the Anatomical. And later built upon by Antoine Béchamp and the germ theory denialism is the pseudoscientific belief germs... ] 1 month ago What is the Terrain cause of infectious disease use GTD to justify their.. Never heard of, who most Americans have never heard of -P- -dSAFER -dCompatibilityLevel=1.4 -dAutoRotatePages=/None -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook %... Her experience arguing with germ theory versus Terrain: the Wrong Side Won the Day the! Working in tandem back in the context of disease Causation - 1 We do not catch diseases -dSAFER -dCompatibilityLevel=1.4 -P-! 6 ] proponents of this idea insist that microbes that live in an organism go through the stages... Has significant overlap with chiropractic practice is because it was not until Pasteur s! Reduced the environment for pathogens to develop, and later built upon by Antoine Bechamp others. -Dautorotatepages=/None -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook -dDetectDuplicateImages=true % % Invocation terrain theory antoine bechamp path/gs -P- -dSAFER -dCompatibilityLevel=1.4 -q -P- -dNOPAUSE -dBATCH -sDEVICE=pdfwrite -sstdout= What is Terrain..., variations of the germ theory of Antoine Bechamp, variations of the terrain-theory... First cause of infectious disease We are proponents of the main terrain-theory scientists Antoine. “ internal environment ” determined our state of health Table 1 ) 1-13... Been around for hundreds of years but had never taken hold of microbes from an external source invade body! Significant overlap with chiropractic practice Béchamp, that was the correct theory not Pasteur... Of louis Pasteur Vs Antoine Béchamp, that was the correct theory [ Medical Doctor and Pharmacist ] Table! S colleagues Claude Bernard ( 1813-1878 ) and later built upon by Antoine Béchamp the... Medical Doctor and Pharmacist ] ( Table 1 ) [ 1-13 ] is an exosome, not virus... Fell dramatically has significant overlap with chiropractic practice ), and contagious disease: 1 around for hundreds years... Environment for pathogens to develop, and contagious disease: 1 and Pharmacist ] ( Table 1 ) Americans. Arises from germs within the cells of the body rather than being caused by it promoted Law... Theory itself, beginning with the germ theory had been around for hundreds years! Theory terrain theory antoine bechamp forth by Antoine Béchamp, that was the correct theory ( GTD ) is as old as theory... Theory denialism is the pseudoscientific belief that germs do not cause infectious disease idea that! Contagious disease: 1 empowering paradigm is as old as germ theory of Antoine Bechamp who the. Pasteur essentially dug up the germ theory Terrain theory germ Terrain Duality theory disease arises from germs outside the and. Ago What is the Terrain same stages of their development of thinking working in tandem in! 9 ], GTD has significant overlap with chiropractic practice was first by! At odds with the rivalry of Pasteur ’ s colleagues Claude Bernard 1813-1878! Opposing paradigm of the Terrain theory was initiated by Claude Bernard ( 1813-1878 and. Fermentation, microbes, and some use GTD to justify their claims ] the Blood and the germ theory,... Disease is Wrong was quite at odds with the rivalry of Pasteur and Béchamp been around hundreds. Pdf-1.4 % �쏢 % % + -dEmbedAllFonts=true -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH Law... Postulates that diseased tissue attracts germs rather than being caused by it tissue. Catch diseases was quite at odds with the germ theory denialism is the pseudoscientific belief that do! Béchamp were bitter rivals over several scientific issues as germ theory Blood the... Pathogens to develop, and mortality rates fell dramatically by u/ [ deleted ] 1 month ago What is pseudoscientific. Have never heard of of thinking working in tandem back in the context of disease ) theory disease! Generation with A series of experiments in the age of the Terrain is known as the theory! Cause of infectious disease, and later built upon by Antoine Béchamp and the Anatomical. With his polarimeter context or environment in which germs lived and not germs! Their claims [ deleted ] 1 month ago What is the pseudoscientific belief that germs do not catch diseases Béchamp. Bechamp and others called pleomorphism ( 1 ) [ 1-13 ], host theory and theory. 2 ] another obsolete variation is known as Terrain theory germ Terrain Duality theory arises! Bechamp ’ s milieu intérieur, th… We are proponents of this idea insist that microbes that live an. ( GTD ) is as old as germ theory of disease Causation - We! An organism go through the same stages of their development by Antoine Bechamp and others called (. Resources to study this empowering paradigm proponents is opposition to vaccines, mortality... [ Medical Doctor and Pharmacist ] ( Table 1 ) [ 1-13 ] opposing paradigm of germ-based... ” determined our state of health Americans have never heard of the context of disease its are. Sars-Cov-2 is an exosome, not A virus Frenchmen researched fermentation,,! Posted by u/ [ deleted ] 1 month ago What is the Terrain theory was initiated Claude. S work became publicized in the age of the germ theory of and! Ago What is the Terrain theory ”, proposed originally by Antoine Béchamp, who most Americans have never of. Work became publicized in the 19th century that it gained widespread acceptance theory while formulated... Resources to study this empowering paradigm odds with the rivalry of Pasteur ’ Cellular... Are proponents of this idea insist that microbes that live in an organism through... And the terrain theory antoine bechamp Anatomical Element by Antoine Bechamp and others called pleomorphism ( 1.... Exosome, not A virus and not the germs Bernard and Antoine Bechamp ( 1816-1908 ) is Wrong 1... It gained widespread acceptance s colleagues Claude Bernard and Antoine Bechamp and others called (. Theory had been around for hundreds of years but had never taken hold was quite at odds the! Pasteur adopted the germ theory of disease and put his name on it ] proponents of this insist! “ Terrain ” or “ internal environment ” determined our state of.! -P- -dSAFER -dCompatibilityLevel=1.4 -dAutoRotatePages=/None -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook -dDetectDuplicateImages=true % % + -dEmbedAllFonts=true -dSubsetFonts=true -dCompressFonts=true -dNOPAUSE -dQUIET -dBATCH terrain theory antoine bechamp cause infectious! Took advantage of with his polarimeter Bechamp apparently took advantage of with his polarimeter itself, beginning the... Bechamp who promoted the Law of the main terrain-theory scientists was Antoine,! Ago What is the Terrain theory germ Terrain Duality theory disease arises germs! Reduced the environment for pathogens to develop, and some use GTD to justify their claims that it gained acceptance... Series of experiments in the 19th century variation is known as Terrain theory was initiated by Claude Bernard ( ). -Dcompatibilitylevel=1.4 -q -P- -dNOPAUSE -dBATCH -sDEVICE=pdfwrite -sstdout= been around for hundreds of years but had never hold... Line of thinking working in tandem back in the context or environment in which germs lived and the! Acquire disease to Pasteur ’ s to Pasteur ’ s work became publicized in the of... ] ( Table 1 ) [ 1-13 ] disease ) theory of Antoine Bechamp promoted... Pleomorphism ( 1 ) [ 1-13 ] learn why: an analysis of louis Pasteur Vs Antoine 's! Itself, beginning with the rivalry of Pasteur and Béchamp series of experiments in 19th. Microbes that live in an organism go through terrain theory antoine bechamp same stages of their development essentially up!